Charles sanders peirce, william james and john dewey. Yong huang is professor of philosophy at kutztown university and the author of religious goodness and. The private and its problems pragmatism, pragmatist feminism, and homophobia. From this rorty makes pragmatic reality, meaning, and truth a. Many political philosophers seem to be drawn to pragmatism while at the same time treating it as a holding philosophy until. Focusing on the tension between naturalist and antinaturalist versions of pragmatism, he argues that the antinaturalist religious views of philosophers such as william james and. Interest will be charged to your account from the purchase date contingencja the balance is not paid in full within 6 months. In this new millennium and global era, a new convergence of american pragmatism and asian confucianism may be well worth considering.
The cultures and eras in which confucianism and pragmatism gestated and thrived were very different. No part of this book may be stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism. Starting from alexander bains definition of belief as a rule or habit of action, peirce argued that the function of inquiry is not to represent reality, but rather to enable us to act more effectively. Rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism with responses by richard rorty, albany. Confucianism and american philosophy reading religion. The aim of this paper is to argue that richard rortys claim that pragmatism is opposed to all varieties of metaphysics is fundamentally mistaken. Mencius also spelled mengzi or mengtzu, a book of his conversations with kings of the time, is one of the four books which form the core of orthodox confucian thinking.
Rorty, pragmatism, intercultural philosophy, comparative philosophy. Richard rorty, pragmatism, relativism, and irrationalism. Well aware that his philosophical hero, john dewey, has had a lasting influence among chinese intellectuals, rorty. Wildcard searching if you want to search for multiple variations of a word, you can substitute a special symbol called a wildcard for one or more letters. Zhu xi codified the sacred texts of confucianism, calling them simply the four books. However, almost all of the essays take issue with some aspect of rorty s neo pragmatism usually focusing on worries over his socalled linguistic turn, which entails a rejection of deweys naturalistic metaphysics pp. Well aware that his philosophical hero, john dewey, has had a. Richard rorty transformed the discipline of philosophy during the last quarter of the twentieth century, while setting it on a new path for the twentyfirst. Introduction pragmatism as antirepresentationalism pragmatism and imagination the public face of pragmatism the liberal ironist conclusion. Because heaven has laid down what is the way to perfect virtue, it is not that difficult to follow the steps of the holy rulers of old if one only.
Contribution to book coping with incommensurable pursuits. This comprehensive introduction explores the life and teachings ofconfucius, and development of confucian thought, from ancient timesto the present today. I see no good in judaism, christianity, or islam good people, yes, but any religion based on a single, well, frenzied and virulent god, is not as useful to the human race as, say, confucianism, which is not a religion but an ethical and educational system. The four books and five classics are the authoritative books of confucianism in china written.
The four books sishu are chinese classic texts illustrating the core value and belief systems in confucianism. Rorty s own books are being rapidly translated and published in chinese, and from the great enthusiasm shown during rorty s monthlong lecture tour in. Asked at the end of his life about the holy, the strict atheist answered with words reminiscent of the young hegel. Review andrew lambert 2012 philosophy east and west 62 1. In his introduction, the editor yong huang states his desire to outline areas of shared interest in rortian and confucian thought. Nov 22, 2016 confucian texts the lunyu analects are the most revered sacred scripture in the confucian tradition. Its origins are often attributed to the philosophers charles sanders peirce, william james, and john dewey. Confucian books are boring if youre interested in holy stories, spiritual miracles, and afterlife thrills. Presumably, richard rortys brand of neopragmatism, which he considered to be a kind of critical footnote 2003, p.
Neopragmatism, language and culture nordic pragmatism. Thinking between cultures pragmatism, rorty and intercultural. After detailing pragmatist reasons for thinking rorty s proposal is justified, i argue that there are more compelling pragmatist reasons to think rorty s metaphilosophical interpretation of pragmatism is rather problematic. Pragmatism is a philosophical tradition founded by three american philosophers. Rorty might easily have counterattacked by suggesting that it was european dedication to philosophic principles and systems that, in some measure, led to concentration camps and gulags. In epistemology, the philosophy of language, culture, value, and politics, the impact of his thought is impossible to measure.
Rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism huang 2nd dd i 32009 1. From the confucian perspective, it is easy to distinguish shustermans neoneopragmatism from rorty s neo pragmatism which remains bound to the socalled linguistic turn of modern philosophy. Neopragmatism, sometimes called postdeweyan pragmatism, linguistic pragmatism, or analytic pragmatism, is the philosophical tradition that infers that the meaning of words is a function of how they are used, rather than the meaning of what people intend for them to describe. The philosophy of richard rorty is the thirtysecond volume in the library of living philosophers series, which commenced with a volume on the philosopher with whom rorty is most often compared, john dewey. The philosopher responds to his critics the vanderbilt library of american philosophy. His father experienced two nervous breakdowns in his later life. Richard rorty was born on october 4, 1931, in new york city. Jul 14, 2010 download free pdf ebooks download pdfs. After detailing pragmatist reasons for thinking rortys proposal is justified, i argue that there are more compelling pragmatist reasons to think rortys metaphilosophical interpretation of pragmatism is rather problematic. In this chapter we attempt to rethink the issue of democratic experimentalism from an ethical point of view and look at its potential for the future by way of drawing on two key thinkers of the late twentieth and early twentyfirst century. Rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism, a collection of twelve essays on the work of richard rorty and its relation to confucian thought, arose out of a conference in shanghai in 2004, where participants were granted access to several of rorty s unpublished manuscripts. Then, your conception of those effects is the whole of your conception of the object.
Provocatively transcending boundaries between philosophy and theology, ancient and contemporary, east and west, natural theology reconfigured revitalises the validity and relevancy of natural theology, a shipwrecked concept in the west, with the aid of eastern confucian axiology and american pragmatism. These books are the book of history, the book of poetry, the book of changes, the book of rites, and the spring and autumn annals. There are thousands of classic textbooks of confucianism, none of them being holy. Goodman 1995 is an introductory essay to an edited collection but provides a useful overview with some emphasis on the neopragmatists broadening of pragmatism. Additional works that contain primary material by rorty. I regard monotheism as the greatest disaster ever to befall the human race. The great learning, the analects of confucius, the book of mencius and the doctrine of the mean. The way of learning to be great or adult edu cation consists in.
A new name for some old ways of thinking by william james, philosophy and the mirror of nature by richard m. Confucianism and american philosophy is a marvelous example of what robert cummings neville has dubbed boston confucianism, which refers to an irenic membership comprising everyone outside of the east asian cultural milieu who treats confucianism as a valuable philosophical resource. His parents, james and winifred rorty, were activists, writers and social democrats. We shall read rorty and also warren frisinas analysis of the problem in analytic philosophy that pragmatism with help from process philosophy and confucianism can help resolve. Phrase searching you can use double quotes to search for a series of words in a particular order. There are many books in the world that can improve our knowledge. Confucianism, also known as ruism, is a system of thought and behavior originating in ancient china. He is the editor of rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism. Slater provides a new assessment of pragmatist views in the philosophy of religion. Pragmatism and religion addresses an important but overlooked issue. With responses by richard rorty suny series in chinese philosophy and culture huang, yong on. The theme of the workshop is richard rorty s and robert brandoms views on. Rorty 1998 is a short, interesting, if somewhat partisan, account of pragmatism s development up to the neopragmatist revival.
The philosophy and religion of confucianism uphold nine different works as its canonical texts, known as the four books and five classics. According to yale university, the sacred texts of confucianism are five books that legend states confucius wrote. Yong huang is professor of philosophy at the chinese university of hong kong. David wong and his critics, both published by suny press.
An engagement between confucianism and the philosophy of richard rorty. It was probably compiled by the second generation of confucius disciples. Download the bible, the holy quran, the mahabharata and thousands of free pdf ebooks on buddhism, meditation etc. His maternal grandfather, walter rauschenbusch, was a central figure in the social gospel movement of the early 20th century. Rortys own books are being rapidly translated and published in chinese, and from the great enthusiasm shown during rortys monthlong lecture tour in. The aim of this paper is to argue that richard rorty s claim that pragmatism is opposed to all varieties of metaphysics is fundamentally mistaken. Here i think the question of commensurability between early confucianism and rorty s brand of pragmatism can be raised again. Amazon renewed refurbished products with a warranty.
In the 12th century, zhu xi codified the sacred texts of confucianism, calling them simply the four books. Mcreynolds channels that obsession to healthy effect in his documentary american philosopher. It should not come as a surprise that most of rorty s books after 1979 consequences of pragmatism 1982, contingency, irony, and solidarity 1989, et cetera were composed of essays that. Pragmatism and religion classical sources and original essays. This book should be of interest to multiple audiences. Stanford libraries official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. Guide to further reading primary works for a complete bibliography of rorty s writings through 2005, see eduardo mendieta ed.
Rorty seems to think that the criterion of pragmatism, action, is the cashout sort of thing that hinges on the whimsy of our belief. Sep 19, 2009 here i think the question of commensurability between early confucianism and rortys brand of pragmatism can be raised again. Pragmatism was developed by americans such as charles sanders peirce,2 william james, and john dewey in the early twentieth century as a corrective to the western enlightenment tradition and its practice of philosophy that largely. How richard rorty found religion by jason boffetti articles. American pragmatism is fertile soil for new growth in western religious thought. John dewey, confucius, and global philosophy researchgate. Rorty s own books are being rapidly translated and published in chinese, and from the great enthusiasm shown during rorty s monthlong lecture tour in china in june 2004. Richard rortys penetrating critique of angloamerican philosophy has prompted many readers to ask what sorts of investigations and analyses might survive a rortian turn in philosophy. This distinctive collection of classical and contemporary readings comes at a time when pragmatism is undergoing a renaissance across a spectrum of disciplines. My sense of the holy is bound up with the hope that some day my remote descendants will live in a global civilization in which love is pretty much the only law. Discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers.
With responses by richard rorty suny series in chinese philosophy and culture by yong huang jan 1, 2010. How richard rorty found religion by jason boffetti may 2004. But in his zeal to embrace american pragmatism and democracy, rorty has adopted perhaps inadvertently at first, but now more. Pdf thinking through confucius download read online free. The film which is really a series of 8 shorts features interviews with richard rorty, hilary putnam, joseph margolis, crispin sartwell, richard bernstein, and many other prominent. Richard rorty, pragmatism as romantic polytheism philpapers. Demonstrates the wisdom and enduring relevance ofconfuciuss teachings drawing parallels between our21st century society and that of china 2,500 years ago,where government corruption, along. It should not come as a surprise that most of rortys books after 1979 consequences of pragmatism 1982, contingency, irony, and solidarity 1989, et cetera were composed of essays that. Rorty would like to replace the talk on confuciuss, platos, heideggers and. The first of the books three sections samples pragmatism s religious roots.
With responses by richard rorty suny series in chinese philosophy and culture at. As rorty states in his response, he does not value the virtue of harmony, either in the self or in the cosmos, and finds no cash value in using terms like the universe or the world in totalistic ways. Variously described as tradition, a philosophy, a religion, a humanistic or rationalistic religion, a way of governing, or simply a way of life, confucianism developed from what was later called the hundred schools of thought from the teachings of the chinese philosopher confucius 551479 bce. Pragmatism is a philosophical tradition that began in the united states around 1870. All are available for purchase on click book images for details. Pragmatism and the philosophy of religion by michael r. How richard rorty found religion by jason boffetti may 2004 but in recent books and essays rorty has expressed the hope that romantic polytheism will come to serve as americas new religious center. Although later in his writings i am thinking of the third and fourth book of his world. Eight decades later, rorty also went to china in 2004, for a visit which resulted, among other things, in the publication of rorty, pragmatism and confucianism edited by yong huang, suny press, 2009. For example, world war ii with quotes will give more precise results than world war ii without quotes. Mencius interpretation of confucianism has generally been considered the orthodox version by subsequent chinese philosophers, especially the neoconfucians of the song dynasty. Pdf rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism with responses by.
They were selected by zhu xi in the song dynasty to serve as general introduction to confucian thought, and they were, in the ming and qing dynasties, made the core of the official curriculum for the civil service. Rorty, pragmatism, and confucianismwith responses by richard rorty, albany. Well aware that his philosophical hero, john dewey, has had a lasting influence among chinese intellectuals, rorty expressed a wish that his own books, which have been rapidly translated. With this volume, the series title serves as a sad reminder of rorty s death at the age of 75 in 2007, while the collection was still in preparation. Rorty, confucius, and intercultural relativism kuangming wu on three contingencies in richard rorty. With responses by richard rorty ebook written by yong huang.
Consider the practical effects of the objects of your conception. Their holy book is called the analects they study this book and tells them what happened in the past. Rorty, berlin, and the confucian daoist complementarity rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism with responses by richard rorty 2009. Yao hsinchung reports that still other scholars hold the pragmatic view that the. Rorty simply considers this a compliment rather than a criticism see, for example, the priority of democracy to philosophy, papers, 1. Richard rorty expanded on these and other arguments in philosophy and the mirror of nature in. Reid on the role of sensations in perception, with a focus on color perception. Apr 28, 2009 rorty seems to think that the criterion of pragmatism, action, is the cashout sort of thing that hinges on the whimsy of our belief. A collection of handselected books on confucianism, chosen on the basis of apparent usefulness and quality. He is the author of religious goodness and political rightness.
But in recent books and essays rorty has expressed the hope that romantic polytheism will come to serve as americas new religious center. Focusing on the tension between naturalist and antinaturalist versions of pragmatism, he argues that the antinaturalist religious views of philosophers such as william james and charles peirce provide a powerful alternative to the naturalism and secularism of later pragmatists such as. Perspectives on rorty and brandom oslo, norway, 2829 october 2010 theme in connection with a visit of professor yajun chen nanjing university, the nordic pragmatism network and the university of oslo will arrange a workshop on neo pragmatism. Rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism offers a fascinating conversation between confucianism, historically the dominant tradition in chinese thought and society, and the contemporary philosophy of richard rorty. Of the three main teachings in chinese culture, confucianism has exerted the most profound and. In his online bio, penn state lecturer phillip mcreynolds confesses his unhealthy fascination with movies. Joseph granges beautifully written book provides a unique synthesis of two major figures of world philosophy. How richard rorty found religion by jason boffetti. Add one setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your universitys proxy server configure custom proxy use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy. With responses by richard rorty, and the coeditor with yang xiao of moral relativism and chinese philosophy.
671 108 514 933 1301 1344 754 639 1250 249 1014 985 1389 556 1033 1406 466 1343 48 1525 1288 402 691 1398 1527 1197 890 511 957 271 1113 1109 398 1061 1401 1016 82